Vespa vs Milvus

Vespa and Milvus are both powerful open-source vector search engines, but they differ significantly in terms of architecture, features, and use cases. Here's a comparison of the two:

1. Overview

• Vespa:

  • Type: Distributed Search Engine
  • Primary Focus: Full-text search, recommendation systems, machine learning, and vector search.
  • Use Cases: eCommerce, news, social media, personalized recommendations, and general search.
  • Key Strengths: Scalable, handles both structured and unstructured data, supports complex queries (e.g., multi-field search, ranking, aggregations).

• Milvus:

  • Type: Vector Database and Search Engine
  • Primary Focus: Efficient similarity search for high-dimensional vectors (commonly used in machine learning, AI, and computer vision tasks).
  • Use Cases: AI-driven applications, image search, video search, recommendation engines based on embeddings, NLP, and other ML-based tasks.
  • Key Strengths: Optimized for vector search, handles billions of vectors with low-latency and high-throughput, integrates with machine learning models.

---

2. Architecture

• Vespa:

  • Data Model: Vespa allows you to define complex schemas, including structured data (e.g., integers, strings) and unstructured data (e.g., text, vectors). It supports both full-text search and vector search for similarity matching.
  • Distributed: Vespa is built for horizontal scalability, meaning it can scale out across multiple nodes in a cluster to handle large datasets.
  • Query Language: Vespa provides a flexible query language that supports complex operations such as Boolean queries, range filters, and aggregations.
  • ML Integration: Vespa supports integrated machine learning, meaning it can run models directly on the data (for instance, for ranking or recommending items).

• Milvus:

  • Data Model: Milvus is designed specifically for high-dimensional vector data, primarily focusing on storing, indexing, and searching vectors generated by AI/ML models. It supports different vector indexes such as IVF, HNSW, and ANNOY for efficient vector search.
  • Distributed: Like Vespa, Milvus also offers a distributed architecture that scales horizontally to handle large datasets (billions of vectors).
  • Query Language: Milvus uses simple query APIs (Python, Java, etc.) to interact with the database. It is optimized for similarity searches (e.g., nearest neighbor search) and does not support full-text search or complex queries like Vespa.
  • ML Integration: Milvus focuses on vector-based similarity search rather than being a general-purpose ML platform. It is commonly used in conjunction with machine learning pipelines.

---

3. Key Features

Vespa:

• Full-text Search: Vespa can handle text-based search alongside vector search, allowing you to combine keyword-based queries with similarity search.
• Real-time Updates: Supports real-time indexing and updating of documents, which is useful for live data scenarios like eCommerce or news.
• Advanced Ranking: Vespa provides built-in support for ranking algorithms and machine learning models to rerank search results based on relevance.
• Aggregation: Vespa supports complex aggregation operations (like SQL-like aggregation) for analytical tasks.
• Query Complexity: Handles more complex queries, such as combining multiple fields in a search (e.g., matching text and vectors simultaneously).

Milvus:

• Vector Search: Optimized for high-performance vector search, including similarity search using algorithms like nearest neighbor search.
• Support for Multiple Index Types: Milvus supports multiple indexing methods (e.g., IVF, HNSW, ANNOY) for fast and efficient vector retrieval, based on different use cases and performance needs.
• Scalability: Designed to scale horizontally, Milvus can efficiently handle billions of vectors and provide low-latency search results.
• Integration with AI/ML Models: Milvus integrates well with other machine learning frameworks like TensorFlow, PyTorch, etc., for vector storage and retrieval in AI-driven applications.

---

4. Performance and Scalability

• Vespa:

  • Vespa is designed to handle both traditional search queries and modern vector search queries, making it highly versatile. However, vector search may not be as optimized as in Milvus.
  • It scales horizontally across multiple nodes and handles large datasets, though its primary strength lies in the integration of text-based search and ranking with ML.

• Milvus:

  • Milvus is optimized for high-dimensional vector data, and its performance shines in scenarios where the primary task is vector similarity search.
  • It supports billions of vectors with low-latency queries and high-throughput indexing, making it ideal for ML/AI workloads.
  • Scalability is a strong point in Milvus, with distributed architecture capable of handling massive datasets with minimal latency.

---

5. Ecosystem and Integrations

• Vespa:

  • Ecosystem: Vespa has strong integration with eCommerce, content management, and media recommendation platforms. It's used in production by companies like Yahoo! and Verizon Media.
  • Integrations: Vespa integrates with other systems for big data processing, recommendation engines, and ranking algorithms.

• Milvus:

  • Ecosystem: Milvus is popular in the AI/ML ecosystem and is commonly used in recommendation engines, image/video search, and other similarity-based tasks.
  • Integrations: Milvus integrates with popular machine learning and deep learning frameworks like TensorFlow, PyTorch, and scikit-learn for training models that generate vectors.

---

6. Use Cases

Vespa:

• eCommerce: Personalized recommendations, search, and ranking of products.
• Content Management: Search and recommendations in media and publishing, combining text and vectors.
• Enterprise Search: Searching across a combination of structured and unstructured data with complex querying.
• News & Social Media: Real-time search and recommendation systems.

Milvus:

• AI/ML Applications: Image/video recognition, similarity-based searches, NLP applications.
• Recommendation Engines: For items based on embeddings or vector representations.
• Semantic Search: Using embeddings to improve search relevance and accuracy.

---

7. Conclusion

• Vespa is a better choice if you need a general-purpose search engine with capabilities for both full-text search and vector search, and if your use case involves complex ranking, aggregation, and combining multiple types of queries (e.g., combining keyword and vector search).

• Milvus is the ideal choice if you need a high-performance vector search engine specifically for AI-driven applications like similarity search in large datasets (e.g., image search, recommendation engines based on embeddings).

In summary, choose Vespa if your primary need is a multi-faceted search engine that combines different data types and operations, and choose Milvus if your application revolves around vector search and needs optimal performance for high-dimensional data.